Buy Mixers Online

How to Choose Mixers on Long Island: A Buyer's Guide

Good mixers make or break a drink. A sour mix with real lemon juice and a balanced sugar level tastes brighter than a syrup-heavy shortcut, and a Bloody Mary mix with visible spice and tomato body stands up to vodka instead of hiding behind it. Our shop organizes 96+ mixers so you can build a full home bar without hunting store to store.

Start with the cocktails you actually drink

Match your mixers to your guest list and your spirits shelf. If margaritas are the house drink, a large-format margarita mix plus a sour mix covers most of the night. If brunch is the occasion, a bold Bloody Mary mix is the anchor. Buy one large bottle over several small ones when you entertain often, since opened mixers keep best refrigerated and used within a few weeks.

• Sour and sweet-and-sour mixes: the workhorse for whiskey sours, margaritas, and daiquiris. Master Of Mixes Sweet N Sour 1.75L is a reliable large-format pick.
• Margarita mixes: look for real lime and a flavor that matches your tequila, like Jose Cuervo Mango Marg Mix 1.75L for a fruit-forward pour.
• Bloody Mary mixes: choose a bold, peppery style such as Bloody Bold Bloody Mary Mix 1L when you want savory depth and heat.
• Tropical and cream mixes: Lemon X Piña Colada 1L and Allens Crème de Menthe Green 1L handle tiki and dessert drinks.
• Spirit-forward shortcuts: Ice Box Manhattan 1.75L and Master Of Mixes Sour Apple 1L speed up classics without a full recipe card.
• Fruit purées and syrups: Allens Blackberry 1L adds color and body to spritzes, lemonades, and sangrias.

Flavor and price guidance

Entry-level mixes run inexpensive and are built for volume, while premium mixes use real juice and less sugar and cost more per bottle. Check the label for juice content and whether the mix is meant to be diluted with spirits only or with water and ice. Large 1.75L formats deliver the best value for parties; 1L bottles suit smaller households and easier storage.

Diet and specialty needs

Some guests want cleaner labels, so browse our organic selection and our kosher options when hosting a mixed crowd. If you are gifting a bottle alongside your mixers, add custom bottle engraving for a personal touch, and find serving ideas in our cocktail recipes.

Local pickup, delivery, and shipping

Order online for free curbside pickup at 1171 Jericho Turnpike in Commack, open 7 days. We offer same-day or next-day delivery across Long Island, including Nassau and Suffolk counties, with free local delivery over $250. Prefer shipping? We ship to the states where it is legal, confirmed at checkout, via UPS or FedEx with an adult 21+ signature required and no PO boxes. Must be 21+ to purchase.