Customer Reviews & Testimonials
For more than 30 years, Commack has trusted Long Island Wine & Spirit Merchant for wine, spirits and champagne. Here is what 369 verified Google reviewers have to say.
Overall customer rating
A 4.7 out of 5 average across 369 reviews, with the large majority awarding a full five stars.
Four reasons Long Island shops with us
The themes reviewers mention again and again, straight from their own words.
A staff that knows its stuff
Reviewers walk in knowing nothing about wine and leave with a bottle they love. Friendly, knowledgeable, no pressure.
A selection that goes deep
From local Long Island wines to rare bottles worldwide, our wine and spirits aisles run 17,000+ deep.
Fair, honest prices
Customers call out competitive prices and real value on everyday bottles, gifts and champagne alike.
Easy to shop and deliver
An easy website plus same-day or next-day local delivery and nationwide shipping where legal.
Real reviews from real customers
A curated selection of genuine five star Google reviews, shown with our owner responses. Read every review on our Google listing.
I walked in not knowing anything about wine and walked out with a bottle of tequilla that I've already bought three more times. The staff just gets it.
Nelson, that might be our favorite kind of story. You came in for wine and found your new go-to tequila, and now you keep coming back for it.
Absolutely loved my visit to Long Island Wine & Spirits! The selection of wines and spirits is impressive, they have everything from local Long Island wines to rare bottles from around the world.
Thank you so much, Roman! We're thrilled to hear you absolutely loved your visit to Long Island Wine & Spirit Merchant!
Excellent selection, easy to navigate website. Prices are competitive, and they always have interesting wines I haven't seen anywhere else.
This wine store is really great. It has a large variety of wines due to different tastes. I ordered Italian white wine and it was really delicious. I recommend Long Island Wine shop to all.
Great store, great staff, they all know their stuff Best place in town
Thank you so much, Ian! We're thrilled to hear you think we're the best place in town what an incredible compliment!
I love this wine shop! They have an amazing selection of local Long Island wines and their staff is super friendly. I always find something new to try here.
Great wine shop with a wide selection. The website is easy to explore and they have many quality wines. Very good experience overall!
Good prices, nice and helpful people.
Nelida, good prices and helpful people is pretty much exactly what we're going for, so that's great to hear. The team here really does care about making sure people feel taken care of when they walk in.
Great wine selection and excellent customer service. Highly recommended!
Excellent selection.
Wide variety of alcoholic beverages and excellent customer service. Highly recommend!
They have a great staff and the store is very nice. 5 star wine store!❤️
Great liquor store. Great service.
Everything I need my favorite wine I go here cause they're the best wine store ever
I love this wine shop; they have all my favorite types of alcohol.
Great customer service for the store
Thank you so much, Wael, for the kind words and 5-star review! We're delighted to hear you had a great customer service experience with us that’s exactly what we strive for at Long Island Wine & Spirit Merchant...
Every review here is real, and earned
Every testimonial on this page is a genuine, verified Google review from a customer in our Commack community. We never pay for reviews, we do not hide honest feedback, and we read every note to keep improving our selection, our service and our delivery. Thirty years in, that is still how a family run shop earns a place in your routine.
- Reviews pulled straight from our Google Business Profile, never edited
- We respond personally to the reviews we receive
- Licensed New York wine and spirits retailer
- Family owned and operated in Commack since the 1990s
Frequently asked questions
What customers most want to know about our Commack wine and spirits shop.
What is Long Island Wine & Spirit Merchant's Google rating?
We hold a 4.7 out of 5 star rating from 369 Google reviews, with 84% of reviewers leaving a full 5 stars. Our customers in Commack and across Long Island have been reviewing us for more than 30 years.
What do customers say about the wine and spirits selection?
Reviewers consistently praise the depth of the selection, from local Long Island wines to rare bottles from around the world. The shop carries more than 17,000 wines, spirits and champagnes, and many reviews mention finding bottles here they had not seen anywhere else.
Is the staff knowledgeable and helpful?
Yes. A recurring theme in our reviews is a friendly, knowledgeable team. Customers describe walking in knowing nothing about wine and leaving with a bottle they love, and they regularly call out helpful recommendations and a no pressure, welcoming atmosphere.
Does the store offer good prices?
Many reviewers highlight competitive, fair prices alongside the large selection. Customers mention good value on everyday bottles as well as on gifts and special occasion wines and spirits.
Can I order online for local delivery or shipping?
Yes. You can shop the full inventory online for same-day or next-day local delivery across Nassau and Suffolk, and we ship wine to every state where it is legal. See our delivery and shipping pages for details and to check your area.
Where is the store located and how do I reach it?
We are at 1171 Jericho Turnpike, Commack, NY 11725, and you can reach the shop at (631) 343-7200. The store is family run and has served Long Island for more than 30 years.
How can I leave a review?
We would love to hear from you. Use the Write a review button on this page to leave a review on our Google Business Profile. Every review, positive or constructive, helps us improve and helps your neighbors shop with confidence.
Are the reviews on this page real?
Yes. Every testimonial shown here is a genuine, verified Google review from a real customer. We never pay for reviews and we do not censor honest feedback. You can read all 369 reviews on our Google listing.
Shopped with us? Tell your neighbors.
Your review helps fellow Long Islanders shop with confidence, and tells us exactly how to get better. It takes under a minute.
Prefer to talk to a person? Call the shop at (631) 343-7200 or contact us.