Same-day or next-day delivery across Long Island  ·  Nationwide wine shipping where it's legal  ·  You must be 21+
Long Island Wine & Spirit Merchant

Western Reserve Tequila

Ohio distilled organic agave spirit with Jalisco roots and real backbone.

5 bottles Same-day or next-day LI delivery Wine shipping where legal
The story

The story behind Western Reserve

Western Reserve Distillers was founded in 2014 by Kevin and Ann Thomas in Lakewood, Ohio, and the agave line carries a fact most drinkers miss: it is legally an agave spirit, not a tequila, because tequila must be distilled in designated regions of Mexico. The 100% organic Blue Weber agave comes from an organic farming co-op in Jalisco, harvested at peak maturity and shipped to Ohio as fresh organic concentrate. There it ferments and runs twice through a custom 3,000 liter handmade copper hybrid pot still built by KOTHE.

Every expression is USDA certified organic, gluten free, additive free, with no added sugar or carbohydrates. The aged bottles rest in charred first run American bourbon barrels from the distillery's own whiskey line, which is where the vanilla and charred corn come from. We have poured these for customers who wanted a clean agave sip without the sweetener tricks, and the answer has stayed the same for years.

The lineup

Explore the Western Reserve range

Five bottles, one organic agave base, and a bourbon barrel program doing the heavy lifting on the aged side. All core agave expressions sit at 80 proof.

ExpressionTypeProof / ABVTasting notes
Western Reserve Blanco 750mLBlanco, unaged80Cooked agave, bright floral, crisp citrus, clean finish
Western Reserve Reposado 750mLReposado, 6 to 8 months80Agave, vanilla, toffee, light baking spice, soft oak
Western Reserve Anejo 750mLAnejo, 12 months80Earthy, complex sweetness, lemon, heavy oak weight
Western Reserve 4yrs Bourbon 750mLBourbon, 4 years80House whiskey line, charred corn, caramel, oak
Western Reserve Sherry Bourbon 750mLSherry finished bourbon80Sherry cask influence, dried fruit, warm spice
Buying guidance

Which Western Reserve is right for you?

Pricing here runs honest for organic, additive free agave. The Blanco lands at $42.99, the Reposado at $47.99, and the Anejo at $59.99, which is a fair step up for twelve months in first run charred bourbon barrels. If you want the whiskey side of the house, the 4yrs Bourbon is $49.99 and the Sherry Bourbon is $69.99. Buy Western Reserve online and we will have it pulled and ready, with free curbside pickup in Commack and free local delivery over $250.

The clean sipperWestern Reserve Anejo 750mL

Twelve months in house bourbon barrels gives earthy sweetness worth a glass and a chair.

The cocktail builderWestern Reserve Blanco 750mL

Bright agave and citrus hold up in a margarita without added sugar muddling the edges.

The whiskey crossoverWestern Reserve Sherry Bourbon 750mL

Sherry finish and warm spice for drinkers who came for bourbon and stayed curious.

Make the most of it

Western Reserve cocktails and pairings

Serve the Blanco in a margarita built with simple syrup, and pour the Reposado or Anejo neat or over one large cube.

Good to know

Western Reserve questions, answered

Is Western Reserve Agave Spirit legally considered a Tequila?
No. Tequila must be fermented and distilled inside designated regions of Mexico, and this spirit is distilled and bottled in Lakewood, Ohio, so it is legally labeled an agave spirit.
Is Western Reserve Agave Spirit made with real agave?
Yes. It is made from 100% USDA certified organic Blue Weber agave sourced from an organic farming co-op in Jalisco, Mexico, then shipped to Ohio as fresh organic concentrate for fermentation.
Does Western Reserve Tequila or Agave Spirit contain additives?
No. The agave expressions are certified additive free with 0 grams of sugar, 0 grams of carbohydrates, and no synthetic colorings or flavorings, and the whole line is gluten free.
What kind of barrels are used to age Western Reserve Reposado?
The Reposado rests 6 to 8 months in first run, charred American white oak bourbon barrels made at the Ohio distillery, which brings vanilla, toffee and soft oak smoke.
Can I get Western Reserve delivered or pick it up locally?
Yes. We offer same-day or next-day delivery across Nassau and Suffolk, free curbside pickup in Commack, and free local delivery over $250. Spirits ship to the states where it is legal, confirmed at checkout, so call (631) 343-7200 to confirm stock.
Search
×