Sheep Dog Whiskey
Peanut butter flavored whiskey, stocked in small amounts in Commack.
The story behind Sheep Dog
Peanut butter whiskey is a flavored whiskey, meaning a whiskey base is blended with peanut butter flavoring to make a sweet, dessert style pour. It is a modern American category, and it drinks more like a liqueur than a straight bourbon, with nutty, creamy, lightly sweet notes and a soft finish.
We keep Sheep Dog in the small corner of our shelves reserved for bottles we only stock one or two of at a time. You will find the 750mL and 1L here in Commack when it is on hand.
Explore the Sheep Dog range
Two sizes of the same peanut butter whiskey, listed here exactly as we stock them.
| Expression | Type | Proof / ABV | Tasting notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sheep Dog Peanut Butter Whiskey 750mL | Flavored whiskey | Sweet peanut butter, soft finish, sipping or mixing | |
| Sheep Dog Peanut Butter Whiskey 1L | Flavored whiskey | Larger bottle, same creamy peanut butter profile |
Which Sheep Dog is right for you?
The 750mL is $17.99 and the 1L is $23.99. Both are flavored whiskey at an easy price, and the liter works out to the better value per ounce if you plan to pour it for a group. Stock is limited to a bottle or two at a time, so call ahead before you make the trip.
Small bottle for sipping neat or over ice after dinner.
Liter size stretches further for shots and mixed drinks.


