Same-day or next-day delivery across Long Island  ·  Nationwide wine shipping where it's legal  ·  You must be 21+
Long Island Wine & Spirit Merchant

Buffalo Trace Bourbon

Kentucky low-rye bourbon, poured in Commack since the last century.

9 bottles Same-day or next-day LI delivery Wine shipping where legal
The story

The story behind Buffalo Trace

Buffalo Trace distilling on the banks of the Kentucky River in Frankfort goes back to 1775, when Hancock and Willis Lee worked the site. Harrison Blanton built the first commercial distillery there in 1812, and Colonel E.H. Taylor Jr. turned it into the O.F.C. Distillery in 1870. The Buffalo Trace name itself arrived in August 1999 under Sazerac, the same year the property took the distillery name.

The flagship uses Mash Bill #1, a low-rye recipe: Kentucky corn well past the 51 percent legal floor, rye at roughly 10 percent or less, and North Dakota malted barley. Limestone water pulled on site, sour mash fermentation, copper column stills, new charred American white oak. No age statement on the label, but the distillery blends barrels averaging 6 to 8 years from its steam heated brick warehouses.

The lineup

Explore the Buffalo Trace range

The lineup runs from the 90 proof flagship to a rye recipe, a wheated mash, and a cream liqueur. Availability shifts weekly, so call ahead on allocated bottles.

ExpressionTypeProof / ABVTasting notes
Buffalo Trace Bourbon 750mLStraight bourbon, Mash Bill #190Caramel, vanilla, light rye spice, clean oak finish
Buffalo Trace Bourbon 1.75LStraight bourbon, Mash Bill #190Same liquid, large format for the back bar
Buffalo Trace Rye Bourbon 750mLRye recipe bourbon90Pepper and dill over caramel, drier close
Buffalo Trace Wheated Bourbon 750mLWheated bourbon90Soft wheat body, honey, less spice, gentle oak
Buffalo Trace Bourbon Cream 750mLCream liqueur30Real dairy cream, vanilla, bourbon warmth, dessert pour
Buffalo Trace White Dog Mash #1 375mLUnaged distillate125Raw corn sweetness, bright grain, fiery finish
Buying guidance

Which Buffalo Trace is right for you?

Pricing here stays honest. The 750mL flagship sits at $49.99, and the 1.75L runs $69.99 when we have it. The Rye Bourbon and the Wheated Bourbon are both $49.99, the Bourbon Cream is $25.99, and the 375mL White Dog Mash #1 is $15.99. The 375mL bourbon is $24.99 and the 50mL nip is $2.59. Allocated bottles move fast, so ask what landed this week. Buy Buffalo Trace online for pickup, or call the counter for what is on the shelf today.

The Weeknight Neat DrinkerBuffalo Trace Bourbon 750mL

90 proof, balanced caramel and oak, no fuss over one large rock.

The Dessert HostBuffalo Trace Bourbon Cream 750mL

Chill it, pour over ice, and dessert is handled in ten seconds.

The Rye CuriousBuffalo Trace Rye Bourbon 750mL

Pepper and dill behind the house caramel, built for a Manhattan.

Make the most of it

Buffalo Trace cocktails and pairings

Smoke and salt flatter this bourbon. Think brisket, sharp cheddar, dark chocolate.
Good to know

Buffalo Trace questions, answered

Is Buffalo Trace hard to find and why is it allocated?
Yes, in many regions. Global demand outran production capacity over the last decade, and bourbon needs 6 to 8 years to mature, so distributors allocate bottles to retailers rather than let supply catch up overnight.
Is Buffalo Trace a wheated bourbon?
No. The flagship is a rye recipe bourbon, Mash Bill #1. The same distillery does make wheated lines such as W.L. Weller and Pappy Van Winkle, but those run on separate production and separate mash bills.
Does Buffalo Trace Bourbon Cream need to be refrigerated?
Yes. Standard spirits do not need refrigeration, but Bourbon Cream contains real dairy cream, so refrigerate it after opening to keep it fresh. Serve it chilled over ice or in coffee.
How long is standard Buffalo Trace bourbon aged?
There is no age statement on the label. The distillery says the flagship is blended from barrels aged on average between 6 and 8 years, drawn from its steam heated brick warehouses in Frankfort.
Can I get Buffalo Trace delivered or pick it up locally?
Yes. We offer same-day or next-day delivery across Nassau and Suffolk, free curbside pickup in Commack, and free local delivery over $250. Spirits are local delivery and pickup, plus shipping to the states where it is legal, never shipped.
Search
×