Same-day or next-day delivery across Long Island  ·  Nationwide wine shipping where it's legal  ·  You must be 21+
Long Island Wine & Spirit Merchant

The Real Mccoy Rum

Aged Caribbean rum, bottled straight, no sugar added.

3 bottles Same-day or next-day LI delivery Wine shipping where legal
The story

The story behind The Real Mccoy

The Real McCoy is an aged rum brand built on a simple proposition: rum the way it comes off the still and out of the barrel, without added sugar or flavoring to smooth the edges. The style is Barbados, column and pot still spirit aged in oak, dry on the finish with the vanilla, coconut and baking spice that wood gives a clean distillate. That is the character we have poured for customers for years.

We cannot tell you the exact founding story or the distillery lineup behind every bottle, and we will not invent one. What we can tell you is what is in the glass: honest aged rum at three age statements, priced where a weekly pour makes sense. The Real McCoy rewards the drinker who wants spirit, not syrup.

The lineup

Explore the The Real Mccoy range

Three ages, one house style. The Real McCoy runs from a young, bright mixer to a twelve year sipper, all dry and barrel forward.

ExpressionTypeProof / ABVTasting notes
The Real Mccoy 3 Yr Rum 750mLAged rumYoung and bright, light oak, good in a rum and cola
The Real Mccoy 5 Yr Rum 750mLAged rumMore vanilla and spice, works neat or in a daiquiri
The Real Mccoy 12 Yr Rum 750mLAged rumDeep oak, dried fruit and toffee, sip it slow
Buying guidance

Which The Real Mccoy is right for you?

The pricing here is straightforward. The 3 year is $19.99, the 5 year is $29.99, and the 12 year is $39.99 for a 750mL bottle. That is a fair ladder for aged rum: start with the three for mixing, step to the five when you want a little more barrel, and keep the twelve for the nights you pour it neat. All three are the same house style, so you are paying for time in wood, not for a different recipe.

The mixerThe Real Mccoy 3 Yr Rum 750mL

Cheap enough to pour with cola or lime without flinching.

The daiquiri drinkerThe Real Mccoy 5 Yr Rum 750mL

Enough barrel to round the edges, still light enough for citrus.

The sipperThe Real Mccoy 12 Yr Rum 750mL

Old enough for dried fruit and toffee, dry enough to drink neat.

Make the most of it

The Real Mccoy cocktails and pairings

Keep it simple and let the barrel show. These are dry rums, so they want salt, fat and a little smoke.

Good to know

The Real Mccoy questions, answered

Is The Real McCoy rum sweetened?
No. The Real McCoy is made in the dry, barrel aged Caribbean style, so you get oak, vanilla and spice rather than added sugar. If you are used to sweetened rums, expect a leaner, more spirit forward pour.
What is the difference between the 3, 5 and 12 year?
Age in oak. The 3 year is bright and light, the 5 year picks up vanilla and spice, and the 12 year turns to dried fruit and toffee. Same house style, more time in the barrel.
What is the best way to drink The Real McCoy 12 year?
Neat or with one ice cube. The 12 year has enough oak and dried fruit to stand on its own, and dilution from ice softens it without hiding the barrel. Save the 3 year for mixing.
Can I get The Real McCoy delivered or pick it up?
Yes. We offer free curbside pickup at our Commack store and local delivery across Nassau and Suffolk, same day or next day. Local delivery is free on orders over $250. Must be 21 or older.
Do you ship The Real McCoy rum?
We ship spirits to the states where it is legal, confirmed at checkout. Rum is available for local delivery across Nassau and Suffolk and for free curbside pickup at our Commack store. Wine shipping is separate and confirmed at checkout.
Search
×