Sugar Island Rum
Two small-batch Sugar Island rums, stocked in Commack.
The story behind Sugar Island
Sugar Island is a flavored rum label, and flavored rum is a category built on cane spirit with coconut or spice added before bottling. Coconut rum leans sweet and tropical, while spiced rum brings warm baking spice and a touch of caramel. Both sit around 21 to 24 percent alcohol in most cases, lighter than standard rum, so they mix easily and pour gently over ice.
We keep Sugar Island in the small-brand section at our Commack store, usually one or two bottles at a time. If it shows out of stock online, call us at (631) 343-7200 and we will tell you what is on the shelf.
Explore the Sugar Island range
The two Sugar Island bottles we stock, both 750mL and both $21.99, one coconut and one spiced.
| Expression | Type | Proof / ABV | Tasting notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sugar Island Coconut Rum 750mL | Flavored Rum | Sweet coconut, light body, mixes with pineapple or cola | |
| Sugar Island Spiced Rum 750mL | Spiced Rum | Warm spice and caramel, good over ice or with ginger |
Which Sugar Island is right for you?
Both Sugar Island bottles are $21.99 for a 750mL. That is an easy price for a flavored rum you keep on hand for mixed drinks rather than sipping neat. We stock them in small numbers, so availability moves. Call the Commack store at (631) 343-7200 before a drive if you want a specific bottle held.
Pours into pineapple juice or cola for a light summer drink.
Warm spice and caramel work over ice with ginger ale.
Sugar Island cocktails and pairings
Flavored rum is a mixer first, so keep the serves simple and cold.