Same-day or next-day delivery across Long Island  ·  Nationwide wine shipping where it's legal  ·  You must be 21+
Long Island Wine & Spirit Merchant

Penelope Bourbon

Small batch bourbon, finished with patience and a little nerve.

3 bottles Same-day or next-day LI delivery Wine shipping where legal
The story

The story behind Penelope

Penelope is a small batch bourbon label built on blending and finishing rather than a single distillery house style. The core whiskey is a straight bourbon, and the lineup you see on our shelf is defined by what happens after: secondary barrels, toasted staves, cask finishes. That approach is common among modern American blenders and it puts the emphasis on the finish rather than the age statement.

We have poured these for customers who want something a step off the standard Kentucky profile. The Rose Cask leans floral and soft on the back end. Architect and Toasted are heavier, oak forward, more dessert than spice. We do not publish claims about the brand's founding or distillery that we cannot stand behind. What we can tell you is what the bottles taste like and what they cost.

The lineup

Explore the Penelope range

Three Penelope bottlings we carry, each a straight bourbon with a different finishing barrel doing the talking.

ExpressionTypeProof / ABVTasting notes
Penelope Rose Cask Bourbon 750mLFinished straight bourbonFloral and soft, red fruit on the finish, gentle oak
Penelope Architect Bourbon 750mLFinished straight bourbonOak forward, baking spice, structured and dry
Penelope Toasted Bourbon 750mLToasted barrel straight bourbonCaramel, toasted wood, vanilla, rounder mouthfeel
Buying guidance

Which Penelope is right for you?

Penelope sits in the mid premium tier and the prices here reflect that honestly. Rose Cask is $79.99, Toasted is $75.99, and Architect is $67.99. These are finished whiskeys, so you are paying for the extra barrel time, not a fancy tube. Architect and Toasted sell through quickly and are often out of stock, so call ahead at (631) 343-7200 before you drive over for either one.

The floral whiskey drinkerPenelope Rose Cask Bourbon 750mL

Rose Cask keeps the red fruit and softness up front without going sweet.

The oak chaserPenelope Toasted Bourbon 750mL

Toasted staves give the caramel and wood depth this drinker actually wants.

The value sipperPenelope Architect Bourbon 750mL

Lowest price of the three and the driest, spiciest pour of the lineup.

Make the most of it

Penelope cocktails and pairings

These are dessert leaning bourbons, so keep the food rich and simple.

Good to know

Penelope questions, answered

What kind of whiskey is Penelope?
Penelope is straight bourbon whiskey, which means a corn based American whiskey aged in new charred oak barrels. The bottlings we carry are finished in secondary barrels, so the base bourbon takes on extra flavor from that second cask.
Is Penelope a Kentucky bourbon?
Bourbon does not have to be made in Kentucky, only in the United States under the federal rules. We do not make origin claims for Penelope beyond what the label states, so ask us in store and we will read the bottle with you.
Which Penelope should I buy first?
Start with Architect if you like dry and spicy, or Rose Cask if you want something softer and floral. Toasted is the richest of the three and the one to buy when you want caramel and wood in equal measure.
Can I get Penelope delivered or pick it up?
Yes. We offer same day or next day delivery across Nassau and Suffolk, free local delivery over $250, and free curbside pickup at our Commack store. Spirits ship to the states where it is legal, confirmed at checkout, so delivery and pickup, plus shipping to the states where it is legal. 21+ with ID.
Why are some Penelope bottles out of stock?
Small batch finished whiskey arrives in limited quantities and sells through fast. Architect and Toasted are frequently unavailable between drops. Call (631) 343-7200 and we will tell you what is on the shelf that day.
Search
×