Same-day or next-day delivery across Long Island  ·  Nationwide wine shipping where it's legal  ·  You must be 21+
Long Island Wine & Spirit Merchant

Misguided Rum

Brooklyn bottled Venezuelan rum with a touch of Caribbean sea salt.

5 bottles Same-day or next-day LI delivery Wine shipping where legal
The story

The story behind Misguided

Misguided was founded in 2020 by James Zinkand, a New York City service industry veteran, alongside a collective of former bartenders. The company is employee owned, and sales reps earn equity based on case sales, which tells you who the brand was actually built for. The rum itself is not distilled in Brooklyn. It is a custom blend sourced from three Venezuelan distilleries, Tiuna, Yaracuy and CIFE, then bottled under the Caribbean Queen's Red Sky label.

The aged expression rests four years in charred ex-bourbon barrels. Both expressions are brought to proof with soft water blended with a touch of real Caribbean Sea Salt, which is why the finish reads savory rather than sweet. The label honors Gertrude "Cleo" Lythgoe, a Prohibition era liquor smuggler who ran out of the Bahamas.

The lineup

Explore the Misguided range

Two expressions, both 80 proof: an aged rum with four years in charred ex-bourbon barrels and a clean silver built for citrus and mint.

ExpressionTypeProof / ABVTasting notes
Caribbean Queen's Red Sky Aged RumAged rum, 4 years ex-bourbon80Vanilla, caramel, toasted coconut, cinnamon, charred oak, sea salt
Caribbean Queen's Red Sky Silver RumUnaged silver rum80Raw sugar brightness, clean cane, crisp citrus finish
Misguided Mojito buildServe, silver rum base80Mint, lime, soda, silver rum backbone
Shaken Piña Colada buildServe, split base80One ounce silver, one ounce aged, coconut, pineapple
Aged rum and gingerServe, aged rum base80Ginger beer, lime, sea salt savory edge
Salted caramel dessert pourServe, aged neat80Pairs with dark chocolate and caramel, salinity forward
Buying guidance

Which Misguided is right for you?

Misguided Rum sits in the house pour bracket, which is the point. The 750mL bottle runs $23.99 at our Commack counter, and the aged Caribbean Queen's Red Sky lands in the same neighborhood as a four year Venezuelan blend that most bars would charge more for by the pour. For a bottle that carries real barrel time and a sea salt finish, that is a working bartender's price, not a collector's. Ask us in store about current stock, since the rum moves fast and we restock on a rolling basis.

The Home Mojito MakerMisguided Rum 750mL

Silver style brightness and 80 proof hold up against lime and mint without disappearing.

The Tiki HostMisguided Rum 750mL

Split base piña coladas want an aged rum with coconut and oak, and this delivers.

The Dessert TableMisguided Rum 750mL

Sea salt proofing cuts salted caramel and dark chocolate instead of fighting them.

Make the most of it

Misguided cocktails and pairings

The sea salt in the proofing pulls savory notes forward, so lean into caramel, chocolate and jerk spice rather than sugary drinks.
Good to know

Misguided questions, answered

Who owns Misguided Rum?
Misguided is an employee owned company founded in 2020 by New York City bartender James Zinkand and a collective of former service industry workers. Sales representatives earn equity stakes based on case sales rather than working on commission alone.
Where is Misguided Rum made?
The brand is based in Brooklyn, New York, but the liquid is distilled and imported from Venezuela. It is a custom blend sourced from three Venezuelan distilleries: Tiuna, Yaracuy and CIFE, then bottled under the Caribbean Queen's Red Sky label.
What does Misguided Rum taste like?
The aged expression shows vanilla, warm caramel, toasted coconut, light cinnamon and charred oak, with a savory sea salt edge from the proofing water. The silver is clean and unaged, with raw sugar brightness and a crisp cane finish.
Is Misguided Rum aged?
The Caribbean Queen's Red Sky Aged Rum rests four years in charred ex-bourbon barrels before bottling at 80 proof. The Silver expression is unaged, so it keeps the raw sugar brightness of the Venezuelan blend without oak influence.
Can I get Misguided Rum delivered or pick it up locally?
Yes. We offer same-day or next-day delivery across Nassau and Suffolk, free curbside pickup in Commack, and free local delivery on orders over $250. Spirits ship to the states where it is legal, confirmed at checkout, so call (631) 343-7200 to confirm stock before you drive over.
Search
×