Forbidden Secret Cordials
Tennessee whiskey meets Wisconsin cream in a bottle.
The story behind Forbidden Secret
Forbidden Secret launched in January 2012 under the Tennessee Spirits Company, and the bottle carries a detail most cream liqueurs cannot: the base spirit is Tennessee whiskey, drawn from the company's own Jailers label. Production runs through Midwest Custom Bottling in Pewaukee, Wisconsin, the same facility behind several well known cream brands, using real Wisconsin dairy cream and natural flavor extracts.
That combination separates it from Irish cream. This is an American cream liqueur at 15% ABV, 30 proof, built on grain whiskey and fresh dairy rather than Irish whiskey. We have poured it for Long Island customers for years, and the people who buy it once tend to come back for the big bottle.
Explore the Forbidden Secret range
Seven expressions, two flavor families, three sizes. Dark Mocha leans coffee and cocoa, White Choco stays soft and sweet, and both pour at 30 proof.
| Expression | Type | Proof / ABV | Tasting notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dark Mocha Cream 375mL | Cream liqueur | 30 | Chocolate and espresso, half bottle, easy to try |
| White Choco Cream 375mL | Cream liqueur | 30 | White chocolate, vanilla softness, small format |
| White Chocolate 750mL | Cream liqueur | 30 | Creamy white chocolate, gentle finish, full bottle |
| Dark Mocha Cream 1.75L | Cream liqueur | 30 | Coffee cocoa richness, party size, best value |
| White Choco Cream 1.75L | Cream liqueur | 30 | Sweet white chocolate, large format, dessert pours |
| Dark Mocha 750mL | Cream liqueur | 30 | Full cocoa profile, currently out of stock |
| Pumpkin Spice 750mL | Cream liqueur | 30 | Seasonal spice, fall release, currently out of stock |
CordialsForbidden Secret - Dark Mocha 750mL$20.99Out of stock
CordialsForbidden Secret - Pumpkin Spice 750mL$20.99
CordialsForbidden Secret - White Chocolate 750mL$12.99
CordialsForbidden Secret - Dark Mocha Cream 1.75L$17.99
CordialsForbidden Secret - White Choco Cream 1.75L$17.99
CordialsForbidden Secret - Dark Mocha Cream 375mL$7.99
CordialsForbidden Secret - White Choco Cream 375mL$7.99Which Forbidden Secret is right for you?
Pricing here runs from the small format up. The 375mL Dark Mocha Cream and White Choco Cream both sit at $7.99, a low entry point if you want to test a flavor before committing. The 750mL White Chocolate is $12.99. Step up to the 1.75L Dark Mocha Cream or White Choco Cream at $17.99 each, and the per ounce math gets friendly fast. The 750mL Dark Mocha and Pumpkin Spice are listed at $20.99 but are currently out of stock, so ask us and we will tell you when they land.
Big bottle over vanilla ice cream for a crowd, no mixing required.
Small bottle, one splash per mug, fits a weekday coffee habit.
Party size white chocolate for frozen drinks and after dinner rounds.