Conundrum Red Blends
California's secret blend, poured in Commack since the beginning
The story behind Conundrum
Conundrum came out of the Wagner family, the Caymus people, and the original blending idea belonged to patriarch Charlie Wagner Sr. Conundrum White landed in 1989. The red waited until 2011, when his grandson Charlie Wagner launched it. Nobody pins this wine to one vineyard or one county. Fruit comes in from Napa Valley, Monterey, Santa Barbara, San Benito, Solano and Tulare, and each lot stays separate until the winemakers blend on flavor and texture rather than appellation rules.
That is the whole trick, and it is why the Conundrum Red Blend tastes the same house style year after year even as the percentages shift. Petite Sirah, Zinfandel and Cabernet Sauvignon carry the core, aged in a mix of oak for soft tannins and that chocolate covered cherry note. We have poured it across this counter for years.
Explore the Conundrum range
Five expressions, one house style. The red leads, but the whites and rose earn their shelf space, and the 3L handles a crowd without a second trip.
| Expression | Type | Proof / ABV | Tasting notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Conundrum Red 750mL | Red blend | 14.6 to 15.1% ABV | Petite Sirah, Zinfandel, Cabernet; dark fruit, soft oak, cherry |
| Conundrum Red 3L | Red blend | 14.6 to 15.1% ABV | Same blend, party format; barbecue and grilled meat |
| Conundrum White 750mL | White blend | Varies by vintage | Aromatic, off dry, bright; the 1989 original |
| Conundrum Blanc De Blanc 750mL | Sparkling white | Varies by vintage | Crisp bubbles, citrus and green apple |
| Conundrum Rose 750mL | Rose | Varies by vintage | Dry, strawberry and melon, light chill |
Which Conundrum is right for you?
Conundrum sits in the approachable California tier, and our shelf reflects it. The Conundrum Red 750mL runs $20.99, the White $19.99, the Blanc De Blanc $21.99 and the Rose $23.99. If you are feeding a table, the Conundrum Red 3L at $99.99 works out cheaper per glass than three bottles and saves you the corkscrew mid-party. Buy Conundrum online and we will have it ready at the counter, or send it out across Nassau and Suffolk.
Smoky barbecue, burgers and a crowd; the big bottle keeps pouring.
Soft tannins, dark fruit, no ceremony required with dinner.
Dry rose served well chilled, easy with grilled fish and cheese.





