Same-day or next-day delivery across Long Island  ·  Nationwide wine shipping where it's legal  ·  You must be 21+
Long Island Wine & Spirit Merchant

Coney Island Carlo Rum

Brooklyn tattoo art in a bottle, 90 proof spiced rum.

6 bottles Same-day or next-day LI delivery Wine shipping where legal
The story

The story behind Coney Island Carlo

Coney Island Carlo Rum comes out of Brooklyn, not the Caribbean, and that is the first thing to know. Carlo Fodera, a tattoo artist who grew up in the bar and restaurant business, built the brand through C&C Distributors of Fine Wine and Spirits and wrapped the labels in authentic Brooklyn tattoo art. The bottle is street culture, not marketing polish.

The rum itself is bottled at 45% ABV, 90 proof, with some listings running to 92. The spiced expression leads with vanilla and soft caramel, then a zippy, balanced spice on the finish. No major competition medals on record, and we will not pretend otherwise. What we can tell you: it drinks clean enough to take neat or on one large rock.

The lineup

Explore the Coney Island Carlo range

The Coney Island Carlo line covers rum, gin, whiskey, vodka and tequila, all built on the same Brooklyn tattoo aesthetic. Rum is the heart of it.

ExpressionTypeProof / ABVTasting notes
Coney Island Carlo Rum 750mLRum90 proofUnaged clear expression, built for mixing highballs and Daiquiris
Coney Island Carlo Spiced Rum 750mLSpiced Rum90 to 92 proofVanilla, soft caramel, zippy balanced spice on the close
Coney Island Carlo Gin 750mLGinSee bottleSame Brooklyn label art, botanical forward, gin and tonic ready
Coney Island Carlo Whiskey 750mLWhiskeySee bottleLabel art carries the line, sipping or mixing weight
Coney Island Carlo Vodka 750mLVodkaSee bottleClean neutral base, built for martinis and mixed drinks
Coney Island Carlo Tequila 750mLTequilaSee bottleAgave expression in the same tattooed bottle format
Buying guidance

Which Coney Island Carlo is right for you?

Pricing sits in the mid tier, which is where a Brooklyn label with real art on it belongs. Coney Island Carlo Rum runs $24.99 for the 750mL, and the Spiced Rum is $26.99. Step across the line and the Gin is $28.99, the Tequila $29.99, the Vodka $27.99, and the Whiskey $33.99. Nothing here asks you to gamble on a $60 bottle. Start with the spiced rum, and if the vanilla and caramel land the way we think they will, work through the rest of the portfolio from there.

The Boardwalk HostConey Island Carlo Spiced Rum 750mL

Pours neat or over one rock for ribs, pork chops and caramel desserts.

The Brooklyn NostalgistConey Island Carlo Rum 750mL

Wants the clear expression and the tattoo art label on the bar cart.

The Cocktail TinkererConey Island Carlo Gin 750mL

Same label family, botanical backbone for gin drinks and spiced rum riffs.

Make the most of it

Coney Island Carlo cocktails and pairings

Vanilla and caramel want smoke and char. Serve the spiced rum with boardwalk and barbecue fare, or shake it into something cold.

Good to know

Coney Island Carlo questions, answered

Who makes Coney Island Carlo Rum?
Coney Island Carlo Rum was created by Carlo Fodera, a Brooklyn tattoo artist who grew up in the bar and restaurant industry. He launched it through C&C Distributors of Fine Wine and Spirits, with Brooklyn tattoo art worked into every label.
Is Coney Island Carlo Rum still in production?
Production status is uncertain. The brand's primary web domain has gone dead, though inventory still moves through select retailers and brokers. We carry it while we can get it, so call ahead at (631) 343-7200 before a long drive to Commack.
What does Coney Island Carlo Spiced Rum taste like?
It tastes strongly of vanilla and soft caramel, finishing with a zippy and balanced spice profile. The sweetness stays in check, which is why it works neat or on one large rock as well as in a cola.
What proof is Coney Island Carlo Rum?
The spiced rum is bottled at 90 to 92 proof, or 45% to 46% ABV. That is a sturdy pour for a spiced rum, so treat it accordingly and keep the ice large rather than cubed.
Where is Coney Island Carlo Rum from?
The brand is rooted in Brooklyn, New York, celebrating the borough's historic tattoo culture. It is an American rum label, not a Caribbean import, and the packaging is the point as much as the liquid.
Search
×