Same-day or next-day delivery across Long Island  ·  Nationwide wine shipping where it's legal  ·  You must be 21+
Long Island Wine & Spirit Merchant

Cayuga Vodka

Finger Lakes whey vodka, five times distilled, made for mixing.

7 bottles Same-day or next-day LI delivery Wine shipping where legal
The story

The story behind Cayuga

Cayuga Clear comes out of King Ferry, New York, in the Finger Lakes, made by Cayuga Ingredients, a dairy processing operation that has handled whey for over 15 years and launched its consumer line around 2021. The base is not grain or potato. It is 100 percent upcycled New York State dairy whey and milk permeate, gathered from cheese plants within a 100 mile radius.

Proprietary yeasts ferment the lactose, then the spirit goes through five vacuum distillations and a charcoal plus silver and platinum filtration. The process is carbon negative and returns filtered water. Cayuga Vodka is certified Kosher and gluten free, and lactose free despite the dairy origin. We have poured the flavored line for years as a value mixer that punches above its price.

The lineup

Explore the Cayuga range

Seven bottlings, one 80 proof base, and flavors built for high volume mixing. The 1L line runs $8.99; the 1.75L is $13.99.

ExpressionTypeProof / ABVTasting notes
Cayuga Vodka 1LStraight vodka80Vanilla, creamy, slightly nutty nose, clean heat
Cayuga Lime Vodka 1LFlavored vodka80Bright lime, built for tonic and soda
Cayuga Orange Vodka 1LFlavored vodka80Orange peel, screwdriver ready
Cayuga Raspberry Vodka 1LFlavored vodka80Ripe berry, soft finish, mixes with lemonade
Cayuga Blueberry Vodka 1LFlavored vodka80Jammy blueberry, best with soda and citrus
Cayuga Lemon Vodka 1LFlavored vodka80Lemon zest, clean and dry on the back
Cayuga Vodka 1.75LStraight vodka80Party handle, same whey base, best value
Buying guidance

Which Cayuga is right for you?

Cayuga Vodka sits in the value tier, and we price it that way. Every 1L bottle, straight or flavored, is $8.99, and the 1.75L handle is $13.99. That is real money for a spirit distilled five times from upcycled New York whey. If you want to buy Cayuga Vodka online for a home bar or a party punch, the liter is the smart buy and the handle is smarter. Stock shifts, so check the listing before you plan the round.

The Home BartenderCayuga Lime Vodka 1L

Lime and tonic covers a crowd without bruising the wallet.

The Party HostCayuga Vodka 1.75L

A $13.99 handle keeps the punch bowl full all night.

The Brunch RegularCayuga Orange Vodka 1L

Orange plus juice makes a screwdriver with no extra work.

Make the most of it

Cayuga cocktails and pairings

Cayuga is a mixing vodka, so pair it with salty, sharp food that cuts the heat.
Good to know

Cayuga questions, answered

What is Cayuga Vodka made from?
Cayuga Vodka is distilled from 100 percent upcycled New York State dairy whey and milk permeate. Proprietary yeasts ferment the lactose, then the spirit is five times vacuum distilled and filtered through charcoal and silver and platinum.
Where is Cayuga Vodka made?
It is made in King Ferry, New York, in the Finger Lakes region. Cayuga Ingredients, a dairy processor with over 15 years in whey handling, launched the consumer spirits line around 2021 after acquiring local distillery infrastructure.
Is Cayuga Vodka gluten free?
Yes. Cayuga Vodka is certified Kosher and gluten free, and it is lactose free as well despite the dairy whey base, because distillation removes the lactose. That makes it a workable option for gluten sensitive drinkers.
Is Cayuga Vodka good for mixing or sipping?
It is built for mixing. Reviewers note a creamy, slightly nutty nose but pronounced heat when sipped neat, so use it in a vodka tonic, screwdriver, Cape Codder or blended frozen drinks where fruit and tonic balance the neutral profile.
Do you deliver Cayuga Vodka on Long Island?
Yes. We offer same-day or next-day delivery across Nassau and Suffolk, free curbside pickup in Commack, and free local delivery over $250. Spirits ship to the states where it is legal, confirmed at checkout, so order for local delivery or pickup at 1171 Jericho Turnpike.
Search
×