Same-day or next-day delivery across Long Island  ·  Nationwide wine shipping where it's legal  ·  You must be 21+
Long Island Wine & Spirit Merchant

Broken Barrel Bourbon

Kentucky straight bourbon, finished on broken staves in steel.

4 bottles Same-day or next-day LI delivery Wine shipping where legal
The story

The story behind Broken Barrel

Broken Barrel starts in Owensboro, Kentucky, where the base whiskey is distilled and aged at least two years in new charred oak at the historic Green River Distilling Co. The mash bill is a high-rye Kentucky standard: 70% corn, 21% rye, 9% malted barley. Founder Seth Benhaim launched the whiskey line under Infuse Spirits before rebranding as Broken Barrel Whiskey Co. in 2019.

The difference is the Oak Bill. Instead of finishing in a second intact barrel, Broken Barrel moves the straight whiskey into stainless steel tanks and submerges a documented recipe of broken staves for 3 to 21 months. French oak, ex-bourbon, sherry cask, even Central Coast Cabernet staves. Blending happens in Los Angeles. We have poured these since they landed on Long Island.

The lineup

Explore the Broken Barrel range

Four expressions cover the range, from a 95 proof small batch to a 115 proof cask strength, plus two stave-specific finishes worth comparing side by side.

ExpressionTypeProof / ABVTasting notes
Small Batch BourbonStraight Bourbon95French oak, ex-bourbon, sherry staves; dark fruit and oak
Cask Strength BourbonStraight Bourbon115Same Oak Bill, undiluted; bold wood and caramel
Amontillado WhiskeyWhiskey finished on sherry stavesCheck bottleNutty amontillado influence, dried fruit, warm spice
Mizunara WhiskeyWhiskey finished on Japanese oakCheck bottleMizunara staves; sandalwood, coconut, soft incense
California Oak BourbonStraight Bourbon88Cabernet cask staves; red fruit, gentle oak
Buying guidance

Which Broken Barrel is right for you?

Pricing here is honest mid-tier. The 750mL Small Batch Bourbon runs $31.99 and the Cask Strength $45.99. The Amontillado and Mizunara whiskeys each sit at $49.99, which is fair for stave-specific finishing you can actually taste. Compare a bottle of Broken Barrel against finished bourbons twice the money and the value holds up. Stock moves, so call the Commack store at (631) 343-7200 before you drive out for a specific expression.

The Everyday Neat PourerBroken Barrel Bourbon Whiskey 750mL

95 proof, sherry and French oak staves; drinks neat or on one rock.

The Proof ChaserBroken Barrel Cask Strength 750mL

115 proof, undiluted Oak Bill; water opens the wood and caramel.

The Wine Drinker CuriousBroken Barrel Amontillado Whiskey 750mL

Sherry stave finish bridges red wine palates into whiskey.

Make the most of it

Broken Barrel cocktails and pairings

The sherry and French oak staves pull dark fruit, so match weight with weight.
Good to know

Broken Barrel questions, answered

Who owns Broken Barrel Bourbon?
Broken Barrel was founded by Seth Benhaim, who launched the whiskey line under Infuse Spirits before rebranding as Broken Barrel Whiskey Co. in 2019. Blending and operations run out of Los Angeles, California.
Where is Broken Barrel Bourbon made?
The base whiskey is distilled and aged in Owensboro, Kentucky at the historic Green River Distilling Co. The stave finishing and blending happen in Los Angeles, California, which is why the label reads Kentucky whiskey finished in California.
What is the Broken Barrel Oak Bill process?
Instead of finishing in a second intact barrel, Broken Barrel moves aged straight whiskey into stainless steel tanks and submerges a measured recipe of broken staves for 3 to 21 months. French oak, ex-bourbon, sherry and Cabernet staves each change the whiskey differently.
What is the mash bill of Broken Barrel Bourbon?
The core bourbon uses a high-rye Kentucky mash bill of 70% corn, 21% rye and 9% malted barley. It is aged at least two years in new charred oak before the stave finishing, meeting straight bourbon requirements.
Can I get Broken Barrel Bourbon delivered or pick it up locally?
Yes. We offer same-day or next-day delivery across Nassau and Suffolk, free curbside pickup in Commack, and free local delivery over $250. Spirits are local delivery and pickup, plus shipping to the states where it is legal, confirmed at checkout. Call (631) 343-7200 to confirm stock.
Search
×