Same-day or next-day delivery across Long Island  ·  Nationwide wine shipping where it's legal  ·  You must be 21+
Long Island Wine & Spirit Merchant

Blue Star Tequila

Night-harvested, unfiltered, additive-free tequila from the Jalisco highlands.

3 bottles Same-day or next-day LI delivery Wine shipping where legal
The story

The story behind Blue Star

Blue Star Tequila was founded in 2024 by industry veteran Tom Carr and a group of lifelong friends, and the liquid comes from 100% Blue Weber agave grown in the highlands of Los Altos de Jalisco. It is distilled near Guadalajara at NOM 1589 and NOM 1654. The agave is cut at night under moonlight, a wine-country habit borrowed to hold the plant's natural sugars at their freshest.

Hearts are slow cooked in traditional stone and brick ovens, fermented without agave fibers in stainless steel tanks, then twice distilled in stainless steel pot stills. Nothing is filtered out and nothing is added, which leaves a raw, textured, full-bodied pour. We have carried small-production tequila for three decades, and this one earns its shelf space.

The lineup

Explore the Blue Star range

Four expressions, all 80 proof, all additive-free. Blanco and Reposado sit on our shelf now; Reposado Honey comes and goes.

ExpressionTypeProof / ABVTasting notes
Blue Star Blanco 750mLBlanco80Unaged, clear, bright citrus, mineral, fresh herbal agave
Blue Star Reposado 750mLReposado806 months new American white oak, vanilla, caramel, agave
Blue Star Reposado Honey 750mLReposado infused806 months oak, highland artisan honey, still additive-free
Blue Star Anejo 750mLAnejo8012 months used bourbon oak, buttery, cinnamon, vanilla
Blue Star Blanco 750mLTommy's Margarita base80Crisp mixing, lime and agave syrup, salt rim
Blue Star Reposado 750mLNeat or rocks80Large rock opens the oak spice and caramel
Buying guidance

Which Blue Star is right for you?

Blue Star Blanco 750mL runs $36.99 and Blue Star Reposado 750mL is $41.99, both in stock at the Commack store. Reposado Honey 750mL is also $41.99 and sells through fast, so call (631) 343-7200 before you drive over. That puts the whole core lineup in the premium $35 to $50 bracket, which is fair money for night-harvested, unfiltered, additive-free tequila. Buy Blue Star online for pickup, or take local delivery.

The Margarita BuilderBlue Star Blanco 750mL

Clean agave and citrus hold up against lime without additives getting in the way.

The Neat SipperBlue Star Reposado 750mL

Six months in new American white oak gives vanilla and caramel without burying the agave.

The Dessert PourBlue Star Reposado Honey 750mL

Real highland honey, no additives, and it drinks like a digestif after dinner.

Make the most of it

Blue Star cocktails and pairings

The raw, textured character wants authentic Mexican food. Keep the Blanco with ceviche and citrus, and let the oaked pours handle grilled meat and mole.
Good to know

Blue Star questions, answered

Who owns Blue Star Tequila?
Blue Star Tequila was founded in 2024 by industry veteran Tom Carr along with a group of lifelong friends. It is produced in Jalisco, Mexico at NOM 1589 and NOM 1654 near Guadalajara.
What is Blue Star Tequila made from?
It is made from 100% Blue Weber agave grown in the highlands of Los Altos de Jalisco. The agave is harvested at night, slow cooked in stone and brick ovens, and twice distilled in stainless steel pot stills.
Is Blue Star Tequila additive-free?
Yes. Blue Star markets itself as unfiltered and additive-free across the range, including the Reposado Honey, which is infused with natural honey from highland artisan beekeepers rather than sweetened with additives.
How is Blue Star Tequila aged?
The Blanco is unaged. The Reposado rests 6 months in new American white oak, the Reposado Honey is aged 6 months in American oak before infusion, and the Anejo spends 12 months in used American oak bourbon barrels.
Can I get Blue Star Tequila delivered or pick it up?
Yes. We offer same-day or next-day delivery across Nassau and Suffolk, free local delivery over $250, and free curbside pickup at our Commack store. Spirits are delivery and pickup, plus shipping to the states where it is legal, never shipped.
Search
×