Same-day or next-day delivery across Long Island  ·  Nationwide wine shipping where it's legal  ·  You must be 21+
Long Island Wine & Spirit Merchant

Benchmark Bourbon

Kentucky bourbon on the Buffalo Trace mash bill, priced to pour.

4 bottles Same-day or next-day LI delivery Wine shipping where legal
The story

The story behind Benchmark

Benchmark was built by Seagram's in the late 1960s as a premium label out of the Four Roses Distillery in Kentucky. Sazerac bought the brand in 1989 and moved production to Frankfort, where it still runs today. The McAfee name honors the 1773 surveyors who walked that land before any barrel did.

What matters to you is the recipe underneath. Benchmark uses Buffalo Trace Mash Bill #1, the low rye, corn forward grain bill shared with Buffalo Trace, Eagle Rare and E.H. Taylor. The core expression rests a minimum of 36 months in new charred American oak. You are paying for the same stills and the same grain, at a younger age and a working price.

The lineup

Explore the Benchmark range

Six expressions, one mash bill, proofs from 80 to 125. The lineup runs from an everyday 80 proof pour up to an uncut, non chill filtered barrel strength bottle.

ExpressionTypeProof / ABVTasting notes
Benchmark Old No. 8 BrandKentucky Straight Bourbon80Caramel, light oak, soft baking spice, easy neat
Benchmark Top FloorKentucky Straight Bourbon86Aged high in the rickhouse, warmer oak, gold medal 2024
Benchmark Small BatchKentucky Straight Bourbon90Master Distiller barrel selection, rounder caramel mid palate
Benchmark Single BarrelKentucky Straight Bourbon95One barrel per bottle, flavor shifts batch to batch
Benchmark BondedBottled in Bond Bourbon100Four years minimum, single season, single distiller
Benchmark Full ProofBarrel Strength Bourbon125Uncut, non chill filtered, entry proof heat, needs water
Buying guidance

Which Benchmark is right for you?

Benchmark is where the value argument gets settled. The 750mL Old No. 8 sits at $12.99, the 1L at $14.99, and a 50mL nip at $0.99 when we have it. Step up the range and you are still inside the $20 to $30 tier for Bonded and Full Proof, which is rare air for a 100 and 125 proof whiskey. If you want to buy Benchmark online and keep a mixing bottle plus a sipping bottle on the shelf, this is the cheapest honest way to do it.

The Weeknight MixerBenchmark Bourbon 1L

A liter at $14.99 makes old fashioneds and Manhattans without flinching.

The Proof ChaserBenchmark Full Proof

125 proof, uncut and non chill filtered, for drinkers who add their own water.

The Gift Under TwentyBenchmark Bourbon 750mL

$12.99, real Kentucky bourbon, and it does not look cheap on the table.

Make the most of it

Benchmark cocktails and pairings

Benchmark's caramel and oak want smoke and fat. Keep the lower proofs neat or over ice with the food, and save the Bonded for the grill.
Good to know

Benchmark questions, answered

Is Benchmark Bourbon made by Buffalo Trace?
Yes. Benchmark is distilled and aged in Frankfort, Kentucky on Buffalo Trace Mash Bill #1, the same low rye, corn forward recipe used for Buffalo Trace, Eagle Rare and E.H. Taylor. Sazerac has owned the brand since 1989.
How old is Benchmark Bourbon?
The core Old No. 8 expression is aged a minimum of 36 months in new charred American oak. The Bonded variant carries at least four years, as the Bottled in Bond Act requires, from a single season and single distiller.
Is Benchmark Bourbon a good bourbon?
It is a genuinely good value bourbon. You get Buffalo Trace grain and stills at a younger age and an entry level price, so expect brighter corn and lighter oak than the allocated labels rather than the same depth.
What proof is Benchmark Bourbon?
The flagship Old No. 8 is 80 proof. The range climbs through Top Floor at 86, Small Batch at 90, Single Barrel at 95, Bonded at 100 and Full Proof at 125, which is uncut and non chill filtered.
Do you deliver Benchmark Bourbon locally or ship it?
We offer same-day or next-day delivery across Nassau and Suffolk, free curbside pickup in Commack, and free local delivery over $250. Spirits ship to the states where it is legal, confirmed at checkout; order Benchmark for local delivery or pickup, 21 and over.
Search
×